Product Design vs. UI Design: Which One Do You Need?

Perhaps you’re starting a new project—a mobile app, website, or even a software tool. You’re excited, but there’s a crucial decision to make before anything else: who do you need to help design this thing? Should you hire a product designer or a UI designer? At first glance, it might seem like a toss-up, but these roles are quite different. Understanding what each designer brings to the table could make or break your project’s success.

Let’s say you’re building an app to simplify home budgeting. You need more than just a pretty interface—you want something that truly helps users manage their money, understand their spending patterns, and ultimately feel confident about their financial decisions. This is where the confusion often kicks in: do you need someone to design the entire user experience or just the interface where users interact? That’s the difference between product design and UI design, and the distinction is more important than you might think.

In this post, we’ll break down the differences, help you recognize which role fits your needs, and guide you in making the right decision for your project. Whether you’re just starting out or refining an existing product, by the end of this, you’ll have a clearer idea of whether a product designer, a UI designer, or even both is the right choice for your venture.

What is UI Design?

While product design is about the whole journey, UI design—short for User Interface design—focuses on the specific touchpoints where users interact with your product. It’s about making those interactions as intuitive, smooth, and visually appealing as possible. If product design is like being the architect, then UI design is like being the interior decorator. You’re not building the house, but you’re making sure it’s comfortable, functional, and beautiful to live in.

A UI designer is responsible for things like the layout of a screen, the typography, colors, icons, buttons, and even micro-interactions like the way a button might change color when clicked. They ensure that your app or website not only looks good but also feels natural to use.

Continuing with our budgeting app example: let’s say you’ve figured out the core features with your product designer—tracking expenses, setting budgets, and receiving financial insights. Now, the UI designer steps in to create the visual system that brings those features to life. They decide on where buttons should be placed for maximum ease of use, what color schemes to use so that everything is easy to read and aesthetically pleasing, and how to guide users through the app without confusion.

The job of the UI designer is to ensure that every visual element enhances the user’s experience. They pay close attention to details, ensuring that each component—from a simple input form to a more complex chart—is not only functional but also engaging. A UI designer’s role is crucial because even the best product can fail if the interface is frustrating or unattractive.

In short, while a product designer maps out the path, a UI designer makes the journey smooth and delightful.

What is Product Design?

Product design is like being the architect of your digital product. A product designer looks at the big picture—focusing not only on how your product looks but also on how it functions, how it feels to the user, and how well it solves the problem it was created to address. Think of product design as the holistic approach to building something that’s both useful and desirable.

Let’s go back to our home budgeting app. A product designer wouldn’t just focus on the interface where users input their expenses; they’d first consider the entire user journey. What are the pain points that people face when trying to manage their finances? How can the app make budgeting easier? What features will not only draw users in but keep them coming back because it adds value to their daily lives? These are the questions that guide a product designer.

From conducting user research to mapping out workflows and wireframes, product designers ensure that the app does exactly what it’s supposed to—solve a problem effectively. They work on features, user flows, and overall product strategy, and they constantly refine and iterate based on user feedback. It’s not just about making something that works; it’s about making something people want to use.

A product designer’s job doesn’t end once the product is launched either. They continue to gather data, observe user behaviors, and make adjustments to ensure that the product grows with its users. In short, product design is about aligning user needs with business goals, creating something that’s as valuable to your users as it is to your company.

3 Key Differences Between Product Design and UI Design

Now that we’ve covered the basics of what product designers and UI designers do, it’s time to break down the key differences between these roles. Although they often collaborate and overlap in practice, their focus areas and goals are distinct.

Scope of Work

The most significant difference lies in the scope. Product design is comprehensive—it covers everything from research and user experience to the strategic direction of the product. Product designers are thinking about how the product functions, the problems it solves, and how it evolves over time. Their role can span the entire lifecycle of a product, from concept to launch and beyond.

UI design, on the other hand, zooms in on the specific aspects of a product’s interface. A UI designer’s role starts after the overall structure and functionality have been mapped out, focusing primarily on creating a seamless, visually appealing experience. They are concerned with what users see on the screen and how they interact with it.

In short, product designers look at the “why” and “how” of the product, while UI designers focus on the “what”—what the user interacts with and how it looks.

User Journey vs. Interface

A product designer views the entire user journey—from the moment someone becomes aware of your product to how they use it regularly and even how they feel about it after their experience. It’s about making sure the product aligns with users’ needs and evolves with them. Product designers are constantly asking questions like: What problem is this solving? What will make users keep coming back?

UI designers, however, hone in on what happens when the user is actively using the product. They’re focused on making sure that when users interact with the app or website, it feels intuitive, easy, and pleasant. In the case of our budgeting app, the product designer would think about how the app fits into someone’s financial life, while the UI designer would ensure that when users input data, the forms are simple, and the feedback is clear and immediate.

Strategic vs. Visual

Product design is more strategic, often tied to business goals and long-term user engagement. Product designers work closely with various teams, including marketing, engineering, and management, to ensure the product fits into the broader business strategy. They might decide what features to prioritize based on user feedback, market trends, or business needs.

UI design, while still strategic in terms of usability, is more visually oriented. A UI designer’s primary goal is to create a beautiful and functional interface that resonates with users. They’re thinking about color schemes, typography, and consistency in design elements to ensure users feel comfortable navigating the product. A good UI designer knows that even the smallest details—like the way a button animates when clicked—can significantly enhance the user’s experience.

When Do You Need a Product Designer?

So, how do you know if you need a product designer? The answer comes down to whether you’re creating something entirely new or refining an existing product. If you’re in the early stages of developing a product—whether it’s an app, a piece of software, or a digital platform—a product designer can be invaluable.

Product designers are best suited for situations where you need to:

• Define your product’s vision: If you’re still conceptualizing what your product is and who it’s for, a product designer can help shape the overall direction.
• Ensure user-centered design: Product designers conduct user research, gather feedback, and make sure that what you’re building aligns with actual user needs.
• Develop a scalable product: If your product needs to grow or adapt over time, a product designer will ensure that the foundations are solid enough to evolve without breaking the user experience.

If you’re building from scratch, need help defining the problem you’re solving, or want to create something that offers long-term value, you need a product designer on your team. They’ll think about the entire product experience and ensure that it meets both user expectations and business goals.

When Do You Need a UI Designer?

You might already have a product that works well but just doesn’t look or feel quite right to users. Or maybe you’re in the middle of building something and need someone to make sure that all the visual and interactive elements work together seamlessly. That’s where a UI designer steps in.

You’ll likely need a UI designer if:

• Your product has the right functionality but lacks visual appeal: If users are struggling to navigate or find your interface unattractive, a UI designer can step in to refine the visual elements.
• You’re focusing on branding and aesthetics: UI designers are experts at creating interfaces that reflect your brand’s personality and make a strong visual impact.
• You want to enhance usability: If users find your app or website confusing or difficult to use, a UI designer can streamline the design, making interactions smoother and more intuitive.

If your primary focus is to improve how your product looks and functions on the surface, a UI designer is who you need. They ensure that the product is not only visually pleasing but also easy and enjoyable to use.

Can You Hire Both?

In some cases, the question isn’t whether you need a product designer or a UI designer—you might actually need both. Product and UI designers bring different but complementary skills to the table, and when they work together, the result can be a well-rounded, cohesive product that’s both functional and beautiful.

Imagine this scenario: you’re developing a complex SaaS platform. You need a product designer to help define what features should be included based on user needs, business goals, and market research. They map out the entire user journey and ensure that the features align with solving the real problems users face. Once the product’s structure and functionality are set, the UI designer steps in to make sure every screen, button, and form is intuitive and visually appealing.

By hiring both, you get a product that:

• Solves real user problems (thanks to the product designer’s strategic input).
• Looks and feels amazing to use (thanks to the UI designer’s focus on visual and interactive elements).

This combined approach is particularly useful for large projects or businesses looking to build products that not only perform well but also create lasting impressions on their users. Collaboration between product designers and UI designers can ensure that every aspect of the product is designed with purpose, from its core functionality to its look and feel.

You might not need both for smaller projects. However, for more complex or high-stakes projects where user experience is paramount, having both roles on board can ensure that no stone is left unturned.

---

So, how do you decide which designer is right for your project? It all boils down to your specific needs. If you’re just starting out and need to define what your product is, or if you’re looking to create a long-lasting solution that aligns with both user needs and business goals, a product designer is probably the way to go. They’ll help you figure out the bigger picture, ensuring that your product solves real problems in a meaningful way.

On the other hand, if you already have a solid product idea or a functioning app but feel that the interface could use a facelift—whether visually or in terms of usability—then a UI designer is the right choice. They’ll take what’s already there and enhance it to provide a smoother, more visually appealing experience for your users.

Of course, if you want the best of both worlds and your project allows for it, hiring both a product designer and a UI designer could be the perfect combination. By bringing both strategic vision and visual refinement together, you can build a product that not only works well but also looks great and keeps users coming back.